- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
When Alabama’s Supreme Court defined frozen embryos as children, the shock and confusion was immediate. Major hospitals pulled fertility services and would-be parents scrambled for clarity on what would happen next.
The debate over reproductive rights in America has long been driven, in part, by opposition to abortion from Christian groups - but this ruling has divided that movement and ignited debate about the role of theology in US lawmaking.
You must log in or # to comment.
So Alabama’s supreme court can rule on mere belief?
“Even before birth, all human beings have the image of God, and their lives cannot be destroyed without effacing his glory,” Chief Justice Tom Parker wrote.
That’s how it looks to me.
Seems like the whole thing is in direct contradiction with the establishment clause.
It seems clear at this point they no longer care about the law or precedent or tradition, they just want to punish and subjugate people they don’t like.
If only SCOTUS didn’t have a right-wing religious majority…
Our entire form of government is antithetical to Christianity. Christians need to keep that religious shit to their homes and churches.
I boggles the mind, this image of god nonsense. If we are made in gods image then gods image also includes Meth addicts and sexual offenders? God must be one crazy bugger.
God must be one crazy bugger
You’ve seen a platypus, right?
Hey now - you just keep right on drivin’.
What I like is the image of God. What I don’t like is the work of Satan.
You sure? In the whole bible Satan kills 10 people in total, because God tells him to, and even Satan is having second thoughts about doing Job so dirty, meanwhile God makes his arrows drunk with blood.
Oh I know, my favorite old testament law: If you neighbour strives against you and is raining blows down upon you; if your wife grabs him by the genitals to delivery you from your assailant you must cut off her hand. Show no mercy. < is that the image of god you like?
You guys need to recognize sarcasm. I was speaking for the judge from the OP.
For a moment, I thought you were saying that the Bible verse about cutting off your wife’s hand because she pulled your attacker off of you by his nuts was sarcasm.
Now I’m picturing God standing there after the woman’s hand got cut off,
“Crap, bro, don’t you recognize SARCASM?”. Shit. I thought you’d know I didn’t want you to cut her hand off. That’s crazy! Dude, you were getting your ass kicked. I mean, it’s a little suspicious that of all the ways she could grab him she went for the balls, but you can’t deny it was effective."
Fair enough, it aint easy sometimes
Removed by mod
Setting aside the fact neither exist… in popular mythology, god is generally responsible for far more atrocities such as genocide, plagues, etc. Satan or the devil on the other hand is largely a scapegoat created by god to blame for the evil he creates in the world.
Mythology is some crazy stuff
I would love to know what this so called justice official’s stance is on the Death Penalty; for or against.
I will look it up later as I am being lazy at the moment.
Christians: “Even before birth, all human beings have the image of God, and their lives cannot be destroyed without effacing his glory[.]”
Trans people: [Exist]
Christians: No, not like that…
Which century is this from
lol you act like judges are impartial
Oppressive theist group argues amongst itself about wha their imaginary friend in the sky wants.
They don’t care what it wants. They care how they can frame what they want to seem like what it wants. What they want is pretty clearly spelled out here: more babies.
Oppressive theist group argues amongst itself about wha their imaginary friend in the sky wants.
Maybe they could exclusively focus on that for a while and get back to us if they ever come to an agreement on whose religion is the only correct one?
Meanwhile the rest of us could get on with the business of progressing society without their constant interference.
Maybe they could exclusively focus on that for a while and get back to us if they ever come to an agreement on whose religion is the only correct one?
The true religion is yoga classes you take at the YMCA. There. I solved religion.
But Edie Brickell told me that it’s a smile on a dog. YOU CAN’T BOTH BE RIGHT!!!
As horrendous as this ruling is, I’m also pissed at the pro-forced birthers that are upset by this ruling. It’s so intellectually dishonest to object to this ruling when it uses the same justifications they use to oppose abortion.
These people pick issues to be passionate on but never actually put in the effort to research. And not just whether their position makes any sense, but what the downstream effects of the position would mean.
The politicians who write these anti-abortion laws are even more lazy. This is literally their job and they should have seen this coming. They could have put in exceptions for IVF from the get-go but they didn’t, because they are more interested in winning points than writing effective legislation.
They could have put in exceptions for IVF from the get-go but they didn’t, because they are more interested in winning points than writing effective legislation.
You can’t square that circle. If you codify your religious myth that “life begins at conception” into law in order to ban abortions, then you also have to outlaw IVF by the very nature of the procedure.
Or ensure all embryos are born. Either way that’s dumb
But they do want to outlaw it. They just didn’t want everyone to know until AFTER the election. That way no one could do anything to stop it.
Unfortunately any theology shouldn’t impact lawmaking.
That statement is rather ambiguous as it could be read to mean it’s unfortunate that theology can’t impact lawmaking, or that it’s unfortunate that theology is impacting lawmaking. Theology shouldn’t impact lawmaking and the fact that it is is the problem. Republicans have been steadily chipping away at separation of church and state for decades now and we’re seeing the impact.
Any hint that a lawmaker is letting religious beliefs dictate their legislation should be an automatic disqualification from office. Politicians shouldn’t even be allowed to mention their religion while campaigning. Instead it’s becoming de rigueur for politicians to affirm their faith on a regular basis, and we regularly have politicians citing religious beliefs in debates about legislation.
The only part of your comment that I disagree with is “unfortunately”.
Fair, my comment was related to the post stating what role theology should play in legislation.
deleted by creator
If you’re “Christian” the odds are great that you do not believe and are in fact against the teachings of Jesus Christ.
Book of Revelations
The one book in the new testament credited as written by John after Jesus’ death in order to bring old testament style apocalyptic messaging, and happens to not include any teachings by Jesus?
Dude retconned Jesus to increase the “likes” and “subscribes”.
Hey I didn’t tell them to put it in their book.
But yes that one. The one where Jesus is a murderer torturing genocidal rapist. It is as equally part of the bible as say the Gospel of John maybe even more so because we have higher confidence that we have mostly what was originally in it vs the Gospels.
Also I disagree a bit, a fair amount of revelations lines up with the Markan Jesus. Granted that author took it a lot further but it isn’t coming from nowhere.
As someone who has two living IVF babies, 8 frozen embryos remaining, and is also Christian, this line struck a particularly strong chord:
“Nobody understands more that an embryo is not a child, than the person yearning for that embryo to be a child.”
Knowing multiple people who have gone through IVF procedures, and have had it fail time and time again, i felt that as well. They were heartbroken, time and time again.
One lf them has a child on the way, and the other has stopped trying, for those who wonder :)
Who could’ve foreseen that restricting reproductive rights could go both ways?
I honestly didn’t. Assuming devout being synonymous with maga, this headline caught me off guard.
Can I just ask why more babies being born is seen as a moral good? I’m dumbfounded because I’ve honestly never in fifty years heard this talking point before.
It’s really this simple. The bible says “Be fruitful and multiply”
When the line “be fruitful and multiply” was first written there were fewer humans on the planet than now live in Houston.
Ehhh, a bit more than Houston. By 2000 BCE there were 20,000,000 humans on the planet, though I believe the majority of those were in China. Genesis was written between 1500-1200 BCE.
A bunch of white people in the united states are worried about birth rates because immigrant birth rates are high whereas white birth rates are on the decline. They’re worried about white people becoming a minority because even though if you asked them they would say no, they know that minorities are treated poorly here.
Yep. It’s called “replacement theory” and it’s a core belief among racist organizations like Nazis, the Aryan nation and the KKK. It’s also talked about constantly on Fox News and other right wing media.
Oh for sure, but the problem is they’re preaching is subtly and if you were’t already on alert that it’s bullshit, it can end up normalizing for some people since it’s not usually framed as “white vs black/brown” but as “ Americans vs enemies”, which sounds a lot less racially charged to mega normies who pay more attention to football and soap operas than they do to politics.
Exactly. They’re subtle about it and it needs to be pointed out as much s possible.
core belief among racist organizations
A bit outdated examples, try these:
CPAC, RNC, John Birch Society, Heritage Foundation
They’re the same picture.
This is also behind the trans panic and concurrent anti-LGBTQ legislation in conservative states.
Sure, they’ll package it with scripture and moralizing, but in the end? It’s all about fear.
I wish everyone would just fuck everyone once and for all so we’re all the same god damned race.
You know damn well they’d find something else to divide us, you just tryna get laid is all 😏
They’ll find anything to divide us except haves vs. have-nots. Which is the true division.
You should run on the "everyone needs to fuck everyone " platform
Minorities are treated poorly pretty much everywhere
Yes, I was just alluding to the fact that majorities typically don’t like to talk about it.
I have heard that there are lot of White people in Europe.
However, many of them are not too keen on moving to USA. For some mysterious reasons. 🤷♂️
I’m not white and used IVF. But definitely you are right on the money.
Because a man in a book said something about going forth and multiplying
Skip to 0:30 for the relevant bit.
I’ve seen the interview. You can tell the guy is just completely lost in the conversation.
But my question is this: I understand the assertion that embryos are somehow human, whatever, and I have a sort of begrudging respect for anyone who commits to that and opposes abortion because it is murder. Fine. Like politically and morally I’m completely opposed to that and I will fight them every step of the way, but at least I can understand and respect their commitment. I think it’s valid to oppose abortion on those grounds, I suppose.
But if the argument is that abortion is wrong because we need more babies to be born, that is a completely different argument. That one says abortion needs to be illegal not because it’s killing babies, but because we have to force women to have babies against their will because babies are good.
And don’t come at me with, “they’ve always just been about control and forced birth” because I know that but I also know there are individual people who are just really committed to the idea of embryos as human life. And the right was sort of constrained by the need to keep that particular wool pulled over those particular eyes.
Is this the moment the mask comes off? I’m just… gobsmacked, really. Killing Roe was the absolute worst thing the GOP could do and everyone knows it. They fucking know it. You would think they would try to settle on making some ground to move the arrow, but walk it back a little bit to cool some of the outrage. But no!
I’m just… this is insane.
Yesterday’s Last Week Tonight showed Tommy Tubervile making that realization in real time. It was pretty incredible.
Would that be the same guy who had trouble grasping the concept of “you don’t actually need to swear on a bible” live on air?
Possibly. He’s extremely stupid.
Possibly. He’s extremely stupid.
And yet he managed to convince enough voters that he’s the best person for the job…
There must be a lot of gullible people in his state.
Because football.
Same guy who wore kevlar to the Jan 6th events? Or am I confusing him with fellow dumbass Mo Brooks?
What they could go after next:
- Same sex marriage
- Gay sex
- Porn
- Contraception
- Vasectomy
- Divorce
- Interracial marriage
What they
couldwill go after next:They already are. And have been for a very long time.
Interracial marriage is safe unless Thomas’ wedding goes on the rocks.
- Dancing.
- Tattoos.
- Foreskins.
- Shrimp buffets.
- …
Maybe they should have learned the complete definition of abortion before banning it
This people are so stupid and they make our laws.
"I think the biggest concerns are that people elsewhere forget about us and they think, ‘Oh they’re just the conservative state, and they’re all country bumpkins. Don’t worry it will never happen here.’
“And the next thing you know, it is happening in other states that are ultra-conservative.”
As a progressive in Texas…fuckin YEAH. Some of us are trying to bring reality back and it’s really annoying to get lumped in with the crazies.
I’m a progressive in Arkansas. I understand that 2/3 of our state vote for terrible people who only want to hurt others. That’s a huge portion. But 1/3 of us are still clinging to sanity.
deleted by creator
Life is about navigating one’s principles versus one’s realities.
Xians do exceedingly badly at this in the meta-modern world.
Gotta Love an argument about what god would want while people suffer.
Feel sorry for those caught up in this and I hope some have a light bulb moment.
